Probetrics — Sports Analytics
NFL slate
Cincinnati Bengals
6-11 last yr · #20 Elo
at
Sun, Dec 20, 1:00 PM ET
Bank of America Stadium
Carolina Panthers
8-10 last yr · #26 Elo
Spread Total Moneyline

The read

On rating alone Cincinnati Bengals are 1.9 points better (#20 vs #26 of 32), and CAR add 0.0 for home field. The clearest mismatch is the third down & red zone: CIN third-down conversion ranks #5, CAR defends it at #30; the other way CAR #25 into CIN's #27.

Who has the edge

Rating
Slight edge
CIN
CIN rated 1.9 points better on Elo (#26 vs #20).
Home & rest
Even
CAR gets 0.0 points for home field.
Quarterback
not priced
Usual starters on both sides — Bryce Young and Joe Burrow — no adjustment.
Passing game
Even
CAR passing ranks #26, CIN defends it at #28; the other way CIN #25 into CAR's #24.
context · not in the margin
Rushing game
Slight edge
CIN
CIN rushing ranks #5, CAR defends it at #27; the other way CAR #17 into CIN's #31.
context · not in the margin
Third down & red zone
Clear edge
CIN
CIN third-down conversion ranks #5, CAR defends it at #30; the other way CAR #25 into CIN's #27.
context · not in the margin
Form (last 5)
Clear edge
CIN
CAR −4.4 per game over the last five, CIN +3.2.
context · not in the margin
Market
not priced
No line yet.
context · not in the margin

The margin, factor by factor

Cincinnati BengalsCarolina Panthers
1469 Elo · #20
RatingThe Elo gap in points — the model's core read on who is better, before the situational pieces below.
CIN +1.9 pts
1427 Elo · #26
road
Home field
not priced
home
Rest
even
Burrow · +5.0 EPA/g
QuarterbackStarter's value against what the team usually gets at quarterback. Only moves when someone other than the usual starter plays.
even
Young · −1.2 EPA/g
+2.2 pts vs CAR D
Offense vs defenseEach offense's scoring rating against the other defense's — what drives the model total. Shown as an edge, though the winner call runs on Elo.
CIN +1.7 pts
+0.5 pts vs CIN D
L W W L L · +3.2
Form (last 5)Average margin over the last five games. Already inside the ratings — listed so you can see when recent form and the rating disagree.
CIN +3.8 pts
L L L W L · −4.4
2 out/IR
InjuriesCount of players listed Out or on IR. Not priced beyond the quarterback.
not priced
6 out/IR
MarketThe consensus spread, read as points. Compare with the model margin above it.
not priced

Bars are in points toward the favored side. Blue factors are inside the model's margin; grey ones are context it does not add on top (form and offense/defense are already in the ratings; injuries beyond the quarterback are not priced).

Dissect the matchup

nflverse play-by-play + FTN charting · 2025 season (last season until three games are in)

Biggest mismatches

  • CIN third-down conversion (#5) against a CAR defense ranked #30 at stopping it
  • CIN epa / rush (#5) against a CAR defense ranked #27 at stopping it
  • CAR defense (#8 interceptions forced) against a CIN offense ranked #27
  • CIN sack rate (#10) against a CAR defense ranked #27 at stopping it
  • CAR yards / rush (#14) against a CIN defense ranked #31 at stopping it

A mismatch is a rank gap of at least a fifth of the league between an offense and the defense it faces on the same measure. Descriptive rows (pass rate, pace, direction) are shown for reading the game, not ranked. ▲▼ mark where the last three games sit clearly above or below the season number, in the direction that helps that side.

Cincinnati Bengals offense vs Carolina Panthers defense

ranks of 32
CIN offCAR defEdge
Identity
Pass rate / Pass rate facedDropbacks as a share of plays. On the defense column: what opponents do against them.66%57%·
Early-down pass rateFirst and second down only — the cleanest read on run-heavy vs pass-heavy.62%51%·
Neutral-script pass rateEarly downs with win probability between 20% and 80%: intent, not catch-up mode.61%55%·
Pass rate over expectedHow much more (or less) a team passes than the down, distance, score and clock predict. nflverse xpass.+1.7%−5.0%·
Seconds per playTime of possession divided by plays — lower is faster.29.330.6·
No-huddle3%9%·
Shotgun82%64%·
Play-action rate / Play-action facedShare of dropbacks with a play fake (FTN charting).16%22%·
RPO rate / RPOs faced9%5%·
Screen rate / Screens faced7%8%·
Pre-snap motion / Motion faced53%60%·
Blitzes faced / Blitz rateFive or more pass rushers (FTN). On the offense column: how often opponents blitz them.20%26%·
Pass rushers faced / Avg pass rushers4.234.29·
Passing
EPA / dropbackThe single best pass-efficiency number; on the defense column, what they allow.−0.02#25+0.12#24·
Pass success rate46%#1448%#22CIN
Explosive pass rateDropbacks gaining 20+ yards.6.8%#277.8%#12CAR
Yards / dropback5.9#216.6#23·
Depth of target (aDOT)Average air yards per attempt — how far downfield they throw, or get thrown at.7.47.8·
Deep-ball rate (20+ air)11%11%·
Short throws (≤5 air)55%52%·
Completion % over expectednflverse CPOE, per attempt. Defense column: what they allow.+1.2#12+1.1#20CIN
YAC / completion4.7#275.1#17CAR
Sack rate / Sack rate generatedSacks per dropback. Lower is better for an offense; the defense column shows sacks they create.5.2%#105.1%#27CIN
Scramble rate2.0%4.6%·
Interception rate / Interceptions forced2.7%#272.9%#8CAR
Throws left / middle / rightDirection shares are shown in full on the row.L 35 · M 26 · R 38L 41 · M 25 · R 34·
Rushing
EPA / rush+0.02#5+0.01#27CIN
Rush success rate45%#441%#12CIN
Explosive rush rateRushes of 10+ yards.9.5%#208.9%#11CAR
Yards / rush4.3#134.4#21CIN
Runs left / middle / rightL 35 · M 26 · R 39L 40 · M 26 · R 34·
Situational
Third-down conversion44%#546%#30CIN
Red-zone touchdown rateDrives reaching the 20 that end in a touchdown.67%#358%#18CIN
Turnovers / game / Takeaways / game1.41#301.11#20CAR
Plays / game6159·

Carolina Panthers offense vs Cincinnati Bengals defense

ranks of 32
CAR offCIN defEdge
Identity
Pass rate / Pass rate facedDropbacks as a share of plays. On the defense column: what opponents do against them.59%59%·
Early-down pass rateFirst and second down only — the cleanest read on run-heavy vs pass-heavy.53%54%·
Neutral-script pass rateEarly downs with win probability between 20% and 80%: intent, not catch-up mode.52%56%·
Pass rate over expectedHow much more (or less) a team passes than the down, distance, score and clock predict. nflverse xpass.−5.3%−1.2%·
Seconds per playTime of possession divided by plays — lower is faster.30.729.4·
No-huddle6%6%·
Shotgun67%60%·
Play-action rate / Play-action facedShare of dropbacks with a play fake (FTN charting).22%27%·
RPO rate / RPOs faced10%6%·
Screen rate / Screens faced6%10%·
Pre-snap motion / Motion faced44%58%·
Blitzes faced / Blitz rateFive or more pass rushers (FTN). On the offense column: how often opponents blitz them.27%18%·
Pass rushers faced / Avg pass rushers4.304.18·
Passing
EPA / dropbackThe single best pass-efficiency number; on the defense column, what they allow.−0.03#26+0.18#28·
Pass success rate44%#2350%#29CAR
Explosive pass rateDropbacks gaining 20+ yards.7.7%#1710.0%#29CAR
Yards / dropback5.7#277.1#29·
Depth of target (aDOT)Average air yards per attempt — how far downfield they throw, or get thrown at.6.97.5·
Deep-ball rate (20+ air)9%11%·
Short throws (≤5 air)52%53%·
Completion % over expectednflverse CPOE, per attempt. Defense column: what they allow.+0.9#14+0.9#18·
YAC / completion5.0#187.0#32CAR
Sack rate / Sack rate generatedSacks per dropback. Lower is better for an offense; the defense column shows sacks they create.5.9%#145.8%#23CAR
Scramble rate5.8%6.4%·
Interception rate / Interceptions forced2.4%#202.4%#12CIN
Throws left / middle / rightDirection shares are shown in full on the row.L 40 · M 21 · R 39L 40 · M 23 · R 37·
Rushing
EPA / rush−0.05#17+0.06#31CAR
Rush success rate42%#1344%#28CAR
Explosive rush rateRushes of 10+ yards.8.9%#2212.0%#27·
Yards / rush4.3#145.2#31CAR
Runs left / middle / rightL 37 · M 35 · R 28L 41 · M 18 · R 41·
Situational
Third-down conversion37%#2544%#27·
Red-zone touchdown rateDrives reaching the 20 that end in a touchdown.57%#1663%#25CAR
Turnovers / game / Takeaways / game1.28#231.24#12CIN
Plays / game5961·

Route-by-route data (which routes are run and how coverage plays them) is not published anywhere public — it is sold by PFF and NGS. Throw depth, direction, play-action, RPO, screens, motion and pass-rush counts above are the public pieces of the same picture.

Cincinnati Bengals · key players

  • Joe Burrow QB21.6/32.4 · 226 yds/g · 17-5 TD-INT · +0.13 EPA/db
  • Ja'Marr Chase WRQuestionable11.6 tgt/g · 32% share · 88 yds/g · 8 TD · aDOT 8.5
  • Tee Higgins WRQuestionable6.5 tgt/g · 18% share · 56 yds/g · 11 TD · aDOT 13.4
  • Andrei Iosivas WR3.9 tgt/g · 10% share · 29 yds/g · 2 TD · aDOT 10.4
  • Mike Gesicki TE3.5 tgt/g · 10% share · 26 yds/g · 2 TD · aDOT 10.0
  • Chase Brown RB13.6 car/g · 60 yds/g · 4.4 ypc · 6 TD · −0.02 EPA/car
  • Samaje Perine RB6.0 car/g · 27 yds/g · 4.5 ypc · 3 TD · −0.00 EPA/car

2025 season, per game. Targets ranked by volume, rushers by carries.nflverse weekly player stats. Target share is the player's average share of his team's targets in the games he played. A player who changed teams carries his own games from last season.

Carolina Panthers · key players

  • Bryce Young QB19.1/30.5 · 193 yds/g · 24-12 TD-INT · −0.05 EPA/db
  • Tetairoa McMillan WR7.2 tgt/g · 25% share · 61 yds/g · 7 TD · aDOT 11.7
  • Xavier Legette WRQuestionable4.3 tgt/g · 14% share · 23 yds/g · 3 TD · aDOT 10.0
  • Jalen Coker WR4.6 tgt/g · 17% share · 44 yds/g · 4 TD · aDOT 10.5
  • Tommy Tremble TE2.5 tgt/g · 9% share · 17 yds/g · 2 TD · aDOT 4.3
  • Rico Dowdle RB13.4 car/g · 60 yds/g · 4.5 ypc · 6 TD · −0.02 EPA/car
  • Chuba Hubbard RBQuestionable9.2 car/g · 35 yds/g · 3.8 ypc · 3 TD · −0.10 EPA/car

2025 season, per game. Targets ranked by volume, rushers by carries.nflverse weekly player stats. Target share is the player's average share of his team's targets in the games he played. A player who changed teams carries his own games from last season.

Season

CINCAR
6-11Record8-10
24.4Points for / game19.0
28.9Points against / game23.0
3-6 / 3-5Home / road5-4 / 3-6
8-9Against the spread11-7
9-8Over / underOvers–unders in this team's games. A tendency, not a lean.8-10
L W W L LLast 5L L L W L

Season numbers are from 2025 until this season has games.

Power ratings

CINCAR
1469Elo1427
#20 of 32Rank#26 of 32
+2.3Offense ratingPoints per game above league average scored, opponent-adjusted.−2.0
−2.6Defense ratingPoints per game below league average allowed, opponent-adjusted. Positive is good.+0.1
Strength of scheduleMean Elo of opponents faced this season.

Elo drives the winner call. Offense/defense ratings drive the total.

Efficiency

CINCAR
0.019EPA / play (offense)Expected points added per offensive play, nflverse. The single best efficiency number.-0.048
0.134EPA / play allowed0.057
250Pass yards / game198
94Rush yards / game114
246Pass yards allowed220
147Rush yards allowed123
1.4 / 1.4Turnovers / takeaways1.1 / 1.4
2.1 / 2.0Sacks allowed / made2.1 / 1.7
18.5First downs / game16.4
37Penalty yards / game44
+5.0 · #11 of 52QB EPA / gameThe listed starter's passing + rushing EPA per game, ranked among starters with three or more games.−1.2 · #35 of 52

Efficiency is from the 2025 season until this one has games. Source: nflverse.

Head to head

2024CIN 34 at CAR 24CIN · CIN covered
2022CAR 21 at CIN 42CIN · CIN covered
2018CIN 21 at CAR 31CAR · CAR covered
2014CAR 37 at CIN 37Tie · CAR covered

How the margin was built

Rating gap
CIN +1.9 pts
Home field
CAR +— pts
Rest
Even
Quarterback
Usual starters — no adjustment
Weather / roof
— pts on the total
Model margin
Model total

Market

Spread
Total
Moneyline

Per-book prices appear once the multi-book feed has this game (about a week out).

Cincinnati Bengals injuries

  • Brian Parker II OTInjured Reserve
  • Ja'Sir Taylor CBInjured Reserve
  • Dax Hill CBQuestionable
  • Ja'Marr Chase WRQuestionable
  • Myles Murphy DEQuestionable
  • Shemar Stewart DEQuestionable
  • Tee Higgins WRQuestionable

From ESPN's report. The model prices the quarterback; other absences are context it does not yet price.

Carolina Panthers injuries

  • Ikem Ekwonu OTOut
  • Taylor Moton OTOut
  • Tershawn Wharton DTOut
  • Bam Martin-Scott LBInjured Reserve
  • Brady Christensen GInjured Reserve
  • Trevor Etienne RBInjured Reserve
  • Akayleb Evans CBQuestionable
  • Chuba Hubbard RBQuestionable
  • Derrick Brown DTQuestionable
  • Devin Lloyd LBQuestionable
  • Haynes King QBQuestionable
  • Jaelan Phillips LBQuestionable

From ESPN's report. The model prices the quarterback; other absences are context it does not yet price.

Informational only. Winner probabilities are backtested and calibrated; spread and total calls are tracked leans. 21+, 1-800-GAMBLER.