Defense vs Position, Measured: Soft vs Tough Defenses
- 27%Soft vs tough NFL defenses, WR receiving yards167.6 vs 128.3 a game; league 148.1
- 37%Soft vs tough NFL defenses, RB rushing yards110.9 vs 76.1 a game; league 93.8
- 9%Soft vs tough NBA defenses, guards' points59.9 vs 54.5 a game; a narrower spread than football
How far apart the defenses are
What a position averaged a game against the softest third of defenses, the league average, and the toughest third. Football defenses differ more than basketball defenses: running backs gained 37% more rushing yards against the softest third than the toughest, guards scored 9% more points.
A game a defense: everything that position did against it. Gap: softest third minus toughest third, as a share of the league average.
How to read a matchup grade
A defense-vs-position rank describes what a defense has allowed, against the offenses it happened to face, so read it as one piece of context beside the player's own role and recent games. Larger samples help: the ranks on our boards use each defense's last 17 games (6 at least), ranked as of each game, so a past split never knows the future.
See the current ranks on the NBA, NHL and WNBA defense tables, and the Matchup column on every props board.
Notes: how long a ranking lasts
The real test of a ranking is whether it carries forward. Split each season in half: a defense that was soft against wide receivers in the first half was not reliably soft in the second. The correlation between the halves ran from 0.14 to 0.31 in the NFL (1 would be a perfect match, 0 none), and a defense landed in the same third both halves barely more often than chance.
Same third: chance alone gives 33%. Flipped ends: the softest third in one half and the toughest in the other, or the reverse; chance gives about 22%.
The steadiest numbers were NBA guards' assists (correlation 0.51) and points, where a defense's scheme shows up game after game. The least steady were wide receivers' yards in the NFL and forwards' rebounds in the NBA.
How we measured it
For every defense and regular season, we added up what the opposing players at each position did against it in every game it played (a game where the position did nothing counts as a zero) and took the average a game. NFL: 2022-2025, positions as listed, fullbacks counted as running backs. NBA: 2023-24 to 2025-26, guards, forwards and centers by listed position.
"Soft" and "tough" are the top and bottom thirds by the season average. For stability, each season was split in half (NFL weeks 1-9 and 10-18; NBA by date), each half ranked on its own, and the two halves compared: the correlation of the two averages, the share of defenses in the same third, and the share that went from one end to the other.
Nothing is adjusted for the offenses a defense faced, so part of what looks like a soft defense is a schedule of good offenses. Halves of eight or nine NFL games are small, and some of the movement is that noise alone.
Questions and answers
What does defense vs position mean?
How much of a stat a defense has allowed to one position: the receiving yards it gave up to wide receivers, the points it gave up to guards. Ranked against the league, it says which defenses have been soft or tough against that position.
How big is the difference between soft and tough defenses?
In the NFL (2022-2025 regular seasons), the softest third of defenses allowed wide receivers 167.6 receiving yards a game and the toughest third 128.3, against a league average of 148.1. In the NBA the gap is smaller: guards scored 59.9 a game against the softest third and 54.5 against the toughest.
Is a good matchup a reason to bet the over?
Not on its own. A rank describes what a defense has allowed, against the offenses it happened to face, and it moves a lot. The books know the same history and set the line with it.
Do defense vs position rankings stay the same through a season?
Not very. Splitting each season in half, a defense finished the second half in the same third as the first half 36% of the time in the NFL and 37% in the NBA, where chance alone would give 33%. Part of that is sample size: half a season is eight or nine NFL games.
More studies
- Break-even odds and prop marginsThe win rate every American price needs to break even, a calculator, and the margin DraftKings, FanDuel and other US books build into player props.
- How prop lines moveHow often player prop lines change between first posting and the start, by how much and how late, in the NFL, college football, NBA, NHL and MLB.
Snapshot taken Nov 11. These are measurements of what the books and the box scores did, not a forecast, and nothing here recommends a bet. Data and analytics only, not betting advice: any bet is your own decision, and we are not responsible for losses. 21+ only. Gambling problem? Call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.