Skip to main content
ProbetricsProbetrics

Player props recap: Oct 12-18, 2026

4,332 player props settled this week and 41% went over their closing line. The biggest line moves, and who beat or missed their line by the most.
Week of Oct 12-18, 2026 (Monday to Sunday, Eastern) · The market and box scores, not picks

NFL

  • 913props settled
  • 48%went over the closing line
  • 52%went under
  • 28voided (player did not play)
How each market settled against the closing line
MarketPropsOverOver and under
Pass yds2850%
Pass TDs2846%
Completions2864%
Pass att2861%
Rush yds9340%
Rush att5147%
Rec yds19446%
Receptions20048%
Rush + rec yds5153%
Interceptions2857%
Longest reception15642%
Field goals made2868%

Green over, orange under, against each prop's closing number. Markets with fewer than 20 settled props are left out.

Biggest line movesFrom the first number most books posted to the one they closed on, as a share of the line.
PlayerPropFirst → closeResult
Tyler AllgeierARI @ LARRush yds21.5 → 47.538 under
Najee HarrisNO @ NYGRush yds21.5 → 34.52 under
Jalen BrooksARI @ LARRec yds13.5 → 21.530 over
Ray DavisBUF @ LVRush yds6.5 → 9.54 under
Jacoby BrissettARI @ LARRush yds6.5 → 9.52 under
Lil'Jordan HumphreySEA @ DENRec yds6.5 → 3.50 under
Bo MeltonDAL @ GBRec yds16.5 → 9.50 under
Kenny GainwellPIT @ TBRush yds9.5 → 13.517 over
Beat the closing line by the mostRelative to the line; lines of 3.5 and up.
PlayerPropCloseResult
Brevyn Spann-FordDAL @ GBRec yds3.535 over
Savion WilliamsDAL @ GBRec yds3.532 over
Josh CuevasBAL @ CLERec yds5.544 over
James Cook IIIBUF @ LVRec yds7.558 over
Omar Cooper Jr.NYJ @ NERec yds14.5103 over
Roschon JohnsonCHI @ ATLRec yds5.534 over
Missed it by the mostRelative to the line; lines of 3.5 and up.
PlayerPropCloseResult
Bijan RobinsonCHI @ ATLRec yds29.5-8 under
Kaleb JohnsonDAL @ GBRush yds10.5-2 under
Geno SmithNYJ @ NERush yds8.5-1 under
Cam SkatteboNO @ NYGLongest reception7.50 under
Jonnu SmithDAL @ GBRec yds5.50 under
Bo MeltonDAL @ GBRec yds9.50 under

NHL

  • 3,363props settled
  • 39%went over the closing line
  • 61%went under
  • 55voided (player did not play)
How each market settled against the closing line
MarketPropsOverOver and under
Points103743%
Goals35730%
Assists105630%
Shots on goal83147%
Saves8250%

Green over, orange under, against each prop's closing number. Markets with fewer than 20 settled props are left out.

Most hockey lines sit at 0.5 or 1.5 and move by price rather than number, so the lists below cover the bigger lines: shots on goal and saves.

Beat the closing line by the mostRelative to the line; lines of 3.5 and up.
PlayerPropCloseResult
Nathan MacKinnonPIT @ COLShots on goal3.59 over
Matt BoldySTL @ MINShots on goal3.58 over
Jack HughesNJ @ DETShots on goal3.58 over
Macklin CelebriniSJ @ DETShots on goal3.57 over
Jason RobertsonDAL @ CHIShots on goal3.57 over
Brady TkachukSEA @ FLAShots on goal3.57 over
Missed it by the mostRelative to the line; lines of 3.5 and up.
PlayerPropCloseResult
Cole CaufieldMTL @ WSHShots on goal3.50 under
Tage ThompsonFLA @ BUFShots on goal3.51 under
Auston MatthewsNYI @ TORShots on goal3.51 under
Matt BoldyMIN @ WPGShots on goal3.51 under
Dylan GarandNYR @ NJSaves28.59 under
Sergei MurashovPIT @ VGKSaves25.513 under

WNBA

  • 56props settled
  • 38%went over the closing line
  • 63%went under
  • 0voided (player did not play)
Biggest line movesFrom the first number most books posted to the one they closed on, as a share of the line.
PlayerPropFirst → closeResult
Gabby WilliamsATL @ GSRebounds3.5 → 4.54 under
Kayla ThorntonATL @ GSPoints7.5 → 6.50 under
DeWanna BonnerATL @ GSPoints8.5 → 7.52 under
Angel ReeseATL @ GSPoints14.5 → 13.514 over
Beat the closing line by the mostRelative to the line; lines of 3.5 and up.
PlayerPropCloseResult
Kiah StokesATL @ GSPoints3.59 over
Rhyne HowardATL @ GSRebounds3.57 over
Jordin CanadaATL @ GSRebounds3.55 over
Gabby WilliamsATL @ GSPoints18.526 over
Allisha GrayATL @ GSPts+Reb+Ast20.527 over
Cecilia ZandalasiniATL @ GSPoints6.58 over
Missed it by the mostRelative to the line; lines of 3.5 and up.
PlayerPropCloseResult
Kayla ThorntonATL @ GSPoints6.50 under
DeWanna BonnerATL @ GSRebounds5.51 under
Tiffany HayesATL @ GSPoints8.53 under
Veronica BurtonATL @ GSPoints10.55 under
Naz HillmonATL @ GSPts+Reb+Ast12.57 under
Gabby WilliamsATL @ GSAssists3.52 under

How this is counted

Every player prop with an over and an under price at a US sportsbook, in games that finished this week. Each prop's closing line is the number most books posted in our last pull before the start, and its first line the number most of the same books posted when we first stored it. Lines are stored from September 2026 (NFL, NHL and WNBA), October 2026 (NBA) and November 2026 (college basketball). A player the books list who could not be matched to a box score is left out rather than counted as a void. A move that came and went between our pulls is not seen. Yes-only markets, such as an anytime touchdown, have no under and are left out.

For the model's picks that week, see the picks recap. For how often lines move in general, see how prop lines move.

Questions and answers

How many player props went over in the week of Oct 12-18, 2026?

41% of 4,332 settled player props across NFL, NHL and WNBA finished over their closing line; the rest went under or pushed.

What is the closing line here?

The number most books posted in the last pull before the game started. A prop is settled against it with the player's box score; a player with no box score line (the player did not play) is a void, as the books treat it. A hockey saves prop counts only for the goalie who started.

Every week

A record of what happened against the books' lines, not a forecast. Data and analytics only, not betting advice: any bet is your own decision, and we are not responsible for losses. 21+ only. Gambling problem? Call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.